Nearly 100 Countries Called For Imminent Regulation Of ‘Killer Robots.’ The U.S., Russia And Israel Disagreed.
A round of UN talks in Geneva, Switzerland on the regulation of autonomous weapons, sometimes informally referred to as “killer robots,” ended early on Saturday morning local time as states agreed to hold another set of discussions to discuss new regulations for the weapons systems within two years.
As the Review Conference of the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons came to an end, around 100 countries supported a call “for legally binding rules within a short timeframe to regulate weapons systems that can identify and engage targets with varying degrees of autonomy,” Reuters reported on Saturday.
However, opposition from Russia, Israel and the U.S. derailed the proposition, which resulted in, according to Reuters, “a watered-down agreement that left open the question of whether future measures would be legally binding.”
Nevertheless, Switzerland’s Deputy Permanent Representative to the UN Julien Thöni, who chaired the meeting, told reporters that the negotiations “show[ed] that even in today’s deeply divided world, multilateral diplomacy can still deliver concrete results.”
However, others were critical of the deal, including Deputy Director for Arms at Human Rights Watch Verity Coyle; the conclusion of talks “does not provide the urgent action needed to agree new rules, but the technology is racing ahead,” she said.
The outcome was one “nobody wanted but everyone could grudgingly live with,” Asia-Pacific Institute for Law and Security Rain Liivoja added.
Advocacy groups such as Stop Killer Robots (SKR), a coalition of over 300 organizations which promotes “a world that rejects the automation of killing,” also lamented the “watered-down mandate that fails to chart a clear path.”
On Wednesday, SKR published a mid-conference press release which showed a map of the various attendees’ “state positions on the next mandate on autonomous weapons systems,” based on their delegates’ interventions during the talks.
The map shows nations like the U.S. and Czechia supporting a “non-legally-binding instrument,” whereas Russia, Belarus, Israel, Poland and Japan are shown to be the only five nations backing a continuation of discussions “without [a] goal.”
The U.S., Russia and Israel are three of the highest investors in AI-driven autonomous weapons systems.
According to a report by the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS), “between fiscal year 2019 and FY 2025, federal agencies awarded 2,255 identified AI-related awards, with $4.1 billion in total obligations.”
In this period, the think-tank claimed, AI-related contracts more than tripled and annual obligations also increased. The Department of Defense accounted for approximately 64% of the AI contracts and 83% of obligations in the six-year period cited.