SpaceX Responds To Texas County Rejecting Data Center Tax Break Application, Warns Of Economic Consequences
Commissioners in Texas’ Cameron County voted on Tuesday to reject scheduling a public hearing in December on a tax break request for a planned data center project by Elon Musk’s SpaceX.
The decision prompted the company to warn the county that a tax break deal was necessary to avoid the risk of greater potential swings in property tax rates.
“The proposed abatement was designed to … provide the County with substantial, predictable new revenue through payments in lieu of taxes (PILOTs), incentivize continued investment, and meet the County’s economic development goals,” Space X said on Wednesday.
“Property owners could now face greater year-to-year fluctuations in tax rates as the equipment depreciates. We look forward to continued discussions with local jurisdictions on how to maximize the economic benefits of these investments while protecting sustainable, long-term tax revenues,” the company added.
On Monday, SpaceX received the go-ahead from the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality, which granted the Musk-owned company with an air pollution permit, to move ahead with plans to build a $24 billion data center and power plant at its Starbase Site, which is located on the Boca Chica Peninsula in Cameron County.
However, SpaceX wanted a 10-year, 100% property tax abatement on the planned project.
“Texas’ property tax rates are not competitive with many other states’ tax rates. Abatement is important to keep Texas competitive for the Project described below, including future expansions and/or reinvestments,” the rocket company claimed in its application,
In the document, SpaceX said that it “estimated capex [capital expenditure] of at least £24 billion in the coming years” and predicted that the project would create 500 new jobs.
The Cameron County officials nevertheless voted against moving ahead with discussions relating to the application in a 3-2 vote. Precinct 2 Commissioner Joey Lopez, who sided with SpaceX in the vote, clarified that a ruling in favor of SpaceX would not mean approving the tax relief, but instead would have allowed Cameron County residents to hear more details of the project.
Chapter 312 of the Texas Tax Code stipulates that public hearings must be held before a “governing body” such as Cameron County can grant a property tax abatement, meaning that the SpaceX request, as Lopez is quoted as saying by Texas television station KRGV, “is dead.”
Although the project itself is still set to move forward, the local ruling is emblematic of wider opposition to the expansion of data centers at both a local and national level. At the midterm elections in early November, voters overwhelmingly backed data center restrictions, with nearly 40 jurisdictions approving measures which would limit or ban the facilities.
Polling also indicated that over three quarters of the American electorate would oppose the construction of a new data center in their local community.
In Texas, which is home to Musk’s heavily AI- and data center-reliant Tesla and SpaceX companies, the midterm debate over the future of the AI infrastructure was particularly prominent.
Democrat Gina Hinojosa, who won the Texas gubernatorial race, has called for a statewide moratorium on the construction of data centers, and Musk, who donated record amounts of money to the campaigns of Texas Republicans, said in the aftermath of the results that “data centers in space [were] looking pretty appealing right now.”